We're now offering free 20-min introductory sessions with select therapists. Book your free in-person or online therapy session today...
We're now offering free 20-min introductory sessions with select therapists. Book your free in-person or online therapy session today...

It’s not a question we’re asked to sit with often in our lives, being a man often just… is. it’s not something questioned because it’s also not something the majority of us chose. It was a given part of our identity.

And so it avoids straightforward answers – it’s not just located in what my dad or father figures told me, it’s not just in what I observed from other boys and men. It’s not just in the rituals and transition of boyhood into manhood or the lifestages of being a man. It’s something we receive and are inducted into, without much thought. We learn the rules of being a man long before we make the choice to be one.

In my own experience, and with so many of the men I’ve come to work with, ‘manness’ was learnt in explicit and implicit ways. Yes, I was told that “men are strong” but I was shown strength meant not crying, by watching the moisture dry in the eyes of men I admired. I experienced it myself, in the awkwardness and discomfort that would appear at the sign of my own tears. By noticing the quiet praise given to someone who never seems to struggle.

And I don’t want to paint a picture that all masculinity is toxic; I was also taught and shown that being a man meant being dependable, protecting others, being courageous and working hard to provide for those you love.

What I’m trying to do is give space to the underside of masculinity. Where I was also shown that achieving these things sometimes also meant hiding fear, enduring sadness and pain privately. Realising that so many men pride themselves on giving and being of support, but receiving support was treated as evidence of our own failure.

Even more so as a Black man in the UK, where class, discrimination & marginalisation have shaped me. Strength & self-reliance aren’t just ideals, for me, they were essential adaptations to environments without much safety or compassion. Even more, the ability to endure & remain composed takes on greater meaning and expression. They were ways I showed love, and found dignity in hardship.

Yet, something which once served us, can limit us too.

As a therapist, I’m interested in the relationship we have between our inner and outer worlds. What we feel, often means something, and that meaning often comes to tell us something we believe about ourselves. So how does that relate to versions of masculinity? Ask yourself this:

When you were a boy, what happens when you’re scared, but always understood masculinity to be fearless?

How do you ask for help, when the acceptable version of yourself (to you and to others) is about being the person depended on?

When uncertainty & vulnerability become indicators of weakness, but are fundamental features of the human experience – what happens to them?

When we haven’t processed these inherited beliefs and messages about being a man, we perform a version of men with these built in tensions: and they make us sick.

So, do men really just need to talk more?

It’s Men’s Mental Health Month, and every November we hear familiar slogans encouraging men to speak about their mental health.

“Men need to open up more”

“It’s okay to talk”, “it’s okay not to be okay”

“Check in with your mates”

Breaking silence and representing something different is important. But, I wonder whether our good intentions place too much responsibility on an individual man, without thinking about the system he finds himself in.

This year I’d like to change the underlying question  from “why don’t men talk?” to “what has happened when they’ve tried?”

And I’ll tell you why. Therapeutically, vulnerability isn’t an individual skill, it’s something that happens in relationships. Our willingness to share our internal world is shaped by whether another can attune and receive it.

If we have learned, through experience, that expressing any vulnerability brings rejection, humiliation or danger, it makes a world of sense why so many men aren’t opening up.

You won’t hear me arguing we should stop saying to men to talk  – that’s as important as ever – but let’s turn more attention to what we are also creating together.

Ask yourself:

  1. Are my male friendships, relationships where my friends can be uncertain without being ridiculed?
  2. Is it safe at work to ask for help without competency or security being challenged?
  3. In our families, can we offer boys and men affection, reassurance and care without expecting them to earn it through achievement or shows of strength?
  4. Do our services recognise the different cultural, relational and social experiences that shape how men understand and communicate distress?

We can’t demand vulnerability or offset responsibility to individual men alone. We need to cultivate the psychological safety necessary to make it possible.

The masculinity we choose

One of the many values of therapy is the opportunity to become curious about how our self came to be, and what part was constructed and what was inherited.

To explore who we are in particular dynamics and who we are told we are supposed to be. And without judgement or criticism, explore which stories still serve me.

I want every man to have the kind of liberated masculinity that means the stories we tell about being a man doesn’t have to be something we unquestioningly accept, or completely reject.

Because when we are liberated, we get to make choices.

I can choose to retain courage, resilience, responsibility and care & protection for others while challenging whether strength requires silencing or abandoning myself.

In my own journey towards a liberated masculinity I’ve decided that it also includes reclaiming tenderness, playfulness, affection & vulnerability as expressions of our masculinity, rather than threats to it. There isn’t a male community I know that isn’t full of these things, but their expressions have all sorts of masculine rules: playfulness is hidden in “banter”, affection hidden in teasing, or tenderness under alot of bravado.

It also for me has meant coming to look at the ways I have benefited from a manhood and masculinity rooted in these social expectations, and the ways it harms me and others.

And it’s difficult work; for me there was alot of grief, a lot of wrestling shame and disloyalty to some of the most significant figures in my life. To my community.

But I didn’t have to completely tear down all the foundations; I also got to open up space for compassion. Compassion for the Men, compassion for the choices they had to make in the circumstances they were in. Compassion for us now, the distances we’ve travelled or not & for what has been necessary to survive. Compassion as part of my work towards the boys and men of the future. I’m reminded of the famous words:

“A society grows great when old men plant trees whose shade they know they shall never sit in,”

So, I’ll end where we opened: “When did you first learn what it meant to be a man?” and if you could choose again, or maybe for the first time, knowing what you know now:

what would you choose to keep, what would you leave behind, and what might you make space for?

Because the masculinity we inherited doesn’t have to be the one we keep.

Written by

Leon White

Senior Clinician, Integrative Counsellor & MBACP

Leon is an integrative counsellor, psychotherapist, and senior clinician at Self Space. Warm and compassionate, he supports clients through trauma, burnout, anxiety, and identity questions, helping them reconnect with their voice, worth, and capacity to heal. Drawing from person-centred, psychodynamic, CBT, somatic, and mindfulness-based approaches, Leon creates a safe, collaborative space where clients can explore what’s hurting, what’s stuck, and what’s possible. He is especially committed to working with marginalised and underserved communities. You can find out more and book a session with Leon HERE.