
I’ve spent a lot of my life thinking about what it means to be a real man. Being gay made that question louder. I heard the rules about how a man should speak, how he should carry himself, how much affection he could show and who he was supposed to love. And I knew that, for some people, who I loved would be enough to settle the question of what kind of man I was.
You can know how ridiculous that is and still feel the pull of it. I have. You can spend years getting good at reading a room, working out which parts of yourself will go down well and which might cost you something. Do that often enough and you can mistake the person you’ve learnt to be for the person you actually want to be.
By the time we’re adults, nobody needs to say the rules out loud. Be useful. Be in control. Earn enough. Take the joke. If you’re struggling, deal with it before anyone has to deal with you. There are men who can tell you exactly what they need to do to get promoted and would struggle to tell their closest friend they’re lonely.
I recognise some of that in myself at work. In leadership, being the person who can handle it becomes part of how people see you. It can feel good to be that person. And then there are days when you’re sitting in a meeting, worried about the same thing everyone else is worried about and using half your energy trying to look like you aren’t. You can get quite far in a career on the strength of being able to do that. You can also end up building a life around being needed and have very little idea what you need yourself.
And then I read the news. Another woman abused by a man she trusted. Another account of men humiliating someone for sport. Another story in which people knew enough to say something and chose to look away. I feel angry at the men who did it. I also think about the ordinary moments in which men decide what they’ll let pass. The joke you let go because you like the bloke who made it. The mate whose version of the breakup you accept even though something about it bothers you. The colleague everyone knows to warn the new starter about.
The harm in those stories belongs to the people who experienced it. Men are responsible for the harm we cause and for what we do when we see it happening. When I think about what we’ve inherited, I think about how early boys learn to fear being laughed at by other boys and how long some men will carry on laughing at something cruel to make sure they still belong.
I think about what it would take to risk a bit of that belonging. To tell a friend you’re worried about the way he speaks to his partner, knowing he might take it badly. To say you’re struggling while you’re still struggling, when there’s no tidy story about how you got through it. To admit that the job you worked so hard to get is making you miserable, even if everyone you love is proud of you for getting it.
I still catch myself wondering what people think of me. I suspect I always will. But I want to get better at asking myself a different question. If I had nothing to prove, what would I say right now?
“I’m hurt.” “I need you.” I wish I’d heard a man say those words when I was a boy. I think it would have made it easier to say them now.
I’m learning to say them anyway.
